Hockey

“Most Important in the Canadiens Rebuild”: Scouts Break Down Importance of 2025 NHL Draft For Montreal

Published: Feb 26, 2025, 12:00 PM
1 min read
Updated: Jul 24, 2025, 10:58 AM
Fact checked by:
Sergey Demidov
A general view shows the Montreal Canadiens on the clock in the third round of the 2024 Upper Deck NHL Draft at Sphere on June 29, 2024

The Canadiens own two first-round picks in the 2025 NHL Draft and is a piece or two away from having the league’s best future (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

The Montreal Canadiens had some intriguing drafts since entering their rebuild after the 2021 Stanley Cup Finals run. We will never forget the 2022 NHL Draft, as the lead-up had Shane Wright going first overall, but a stellar season set the front office’s sights on Juraj Slafkovsky with that pick. Then, the Canadiens went off the board the following season with the fifth-overall pick, alienating some of their fans, when they selected David Reinbacher over Matvei Michkov. However, in 2024, the Canadiens righted the ship by taking Russian superstar Ivan Demidov in the same fifth slot. Montreal also landed Michael Hage, a breakout star in the NCAA this season, with the 21st overall pick in 2024.

All those drafts helped the Canadiens to build up one of the top prospect pools in the league, but scouts are now pegging the 2025 NHL Draft as the most crucial one of their rebuild. If the 2024 draft solidified the Canadiens’ rebuild being on the right path, then scouts think the 2025 edition could turn it into one of the stronger rebuilds in recent memory.

“This year’s NHL Draft could be the most important in the Canadiens rebuild,” a rival NHL scout told RG.

“It’s scary to think they could land another top-ten pick if their season continues to crater and also get a top-20 pick from the Calgary Flames. At least 29 teams in the league would kill for the Canadiens’ prospect pool, maybe more, and it’s about to get even deeper.”

With the Canadiens reportedly looking to add a third 1st-round pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, the polled scouts may not be too far off.

Canadiens Have Options with Their Picks

There will be plenty of rumors about how the Canadiens will deal with their abundance of draft picks in the lead-up to the draft. They have nine picks in the first four rounds of this year’s draft for now, and if you map out their roster over the next few seasons, there aren’t many more spots to fill. It’s getting to the point where the Canadiens will be stuck with excellent NHL-ready prospects in the AHL without a place to play.

If the season ended today and the draft lottery kept the same order as last year, Montreal would have the eighth and 16th overall picks, unless they’re able to extract an additional first-round pick between now and March 7.

The draft class quality begins to drop after the first five projected picks, but there are some intriguing options if the Canadiens stay in the 8-16 range. Interesting options like Caleb Desnoyers, Jake O’Brien, Viktor Eklund, Roger McQueen and more could very likely be available in the later part of the top-10 and into the teens.

It wouldn’t be the first time scouts told us about the potential of Roger McQueen in this year’s draft. McQueen has been out since October with an injury, but he had as high of a chance of going first overall as anyone at one point this season. With his injury concerns, it may not be the case anymore, but as an NHL scout told RG earlier this month, McQueen’s potential is untapped.

“Take away the injuries, the inconsistencies, the late birthday. McQueen is a top-ten pick in this year’s draft who has first-overall qualities.”

Outside of McQueen, NHL scouts are circling two other WHL prospects as gems in that range, while a source from the QMJHL is fighting for home-grown Quebec talent that would be a nice fit in Montreal.

“Radim Mrtka and Carter Bear are two players in the dub (WHL) who are rising after some impressive seasons,” the NHL scout adamantly told RG. “Mrtka is a shutdown right-shot defenseman who could sneak into the top-ten like Reinbacher a couple of seasons ago, while Bear is a physical, hard-nosed forward who is turning heads with the number of points he’s putting up this season. You really can’t go wrong with either.”

Mrtka could be seen as a redundant pick if the Canadiens believe David Reinbacher is still the guy, but Bear is an intriguing option. The Canadiens have plenty of offensive skills in their pipeline and on their roster, but they don’t have the mix of skill and grit that Bear brings. However, Bear isn’t the only power-forward kind of player in this draft that is seemingly taking the CHL by storm.

“If you’re asking me who the Canadiens should pick in the mid-first-round, it’s Justin Carbonneau. We know Montreal loves to have a home-grown star in their lineup, and I’d personally love to see him stay in Quebec,” the QMJHL said. “Carbonneau could be the elite Quebecois scorer they thought they were getting when they acquired Jonathan Drouin.”

An Alternate Draft Strategy

The polled scouts didn’t all say to hold on to both picks and take two swings. Some believe the Canadiens are in a spot where they can package two of the first-rounders together and make an enormous splash at this year’s draft. It would take everything working in their favor, but some believe it isn’t that far outside the realm of possibility.

“The worst thing that could’ve happened for the Canadiens’ rebuild was if they had continued to win enough this season to get a playoff spot and Calgary also snuck in. Montreal would’ve had two mid-first-round picks and would’ve been stuck with two chances to get it wrong in a below-average 5-20 range compared to past years,” an NHL scout remarked. “Now they have their own pick that only continues to get better, and the Flames are also beginning to lose more than win. They could be sitting with two top-15 in June and the opportunity to package those together to land a key asset for their rebuild.”

Another scout shared a similar sentiment, but they are more on the side that the Canadiens could earn a top-five pick without having to trade.

“The Canadiens could still get a top-five pick with their selection if they keep losing, but if not, I’d target a team who could use two top-15 prospects with a depleted pipeline and trade up to get one of those top-five guys,” said one scout. “I look at a team like the Seattle Kraken or the Nashville Predators. Would they give the Canadiens a top-five pick if they could get picks seven and 12 or something in that range?”

So, the question had to be asked: if the Predators or Kraken would make that deal, why would it be a good move for the Canadiens instead of taking two guys like McQueen and Mrtka?

“The top five in this draft is absolutely stacked. If you’re the Canadiens and you can take a guy like Porter Martone, instead of two lottery tickets on McQueen and Mrtka, you make that trade a million times out of a million. Imagine Martone, Michael Misa, or even Caleb Desnoyers added to Demidov, Hage, Slafkovsky, Nick Suzuki, Cole Caufield, Lane Hutson, David Reinbacher, and Jacob Fowler. The return to the glory years wouldn’t be far off.”

One thing is sure, Kent Hughes and the Montreal front office have put themselves in a great spot heading into the 2025 NHL Draft. The only question is how creative they are willing to get with their abundance of draft capital.

NHL Reporter
Nate Duffett is a Canadian sports writer who specializes in hockey. He began his writing career in the betting space but has since expanded into journalism, covering analysis and news from the NHL, MLB, NFL and NCAA. His other work can be found at ClutchPoints, but RG is his official home for exclusive content and analysis on key topics in sports.
Interests:
NHL
NBA
NFL
Prospects
Scouting
Coaching

More RG Exclusive Interviews

Hockey
Interview
Ivan Prosvetov Eyes Flames’ Starting Role, Ready For McDavid

Returning NHL goalie Ivan Prosvetov joins the Calgary Flames on a one-year deal, determined to secure the starter’s job and face star Connor McDavid.

6
07/23/2025
Sergey Demidov
Sergey Demidov
Ivan Prosvetov Eyes Flames’ Starting Role, Ready For McDavid
Hockey
Interview
Jeff Gorton, Canadiens See Serious Value in Their Goaltending

Jeff Gorton sat down with RG in an exclusive interview and discussed the present and future states of his team’s goaltending.

8
07/20/2025
James Murphy
James Murphy
Jeff Gorton, Canadiens See Serious Value in Their Goaltending
Hockey
Interview
Source: McKenna Sweepstakes Expected to Spur Earlier NHL Trade Activity

Parity stalled trades this summer, but the 2026 McKenna sweepstakes may spark early NHL sell-offs by U.S. Thanksgiving, sources say.

12
07/19/2025
Marco D'Amico
Marco D'Amico
Source: McKenna Sweepstakes Expected to Spur Earlier NHL Trade Activity
Hockey
Interview
“It Was Tough”: Orlov Says Limited Role With Canes Took Mental Toll

Dmitry Orlov reveals the mental toll of his reduced role in Carolina, saying he felt overlooked and spent long stretches away from his family.

9
07/18/2025
Daria Tuboltseva
Daria Tuboltseva
“It Was Tough”: Orlov Says Limited Role With Canes Took Mental Toll
Prev
...
Next

Hockey Writers

James Murphy
James Murphy
NHL Reporter

James Murphy is a veteran sports journalist covering the NHL, NCAA and CHL hockey for RG.

With 25 years of experience covering the Bruins, the NHL, NCAA, CHL and more, Murphy has seen it all when it comes to hockey. His hockey black book is filled with Hall of Famers, current players, coaches, management, scouts and a diverse array of hockey media personalities who have lived and worked in and around the game. Murphy also currently co-hosts The Eye Test podcast with Pierre McGuire and, along with McGuire, interviews NHL owners and executives, as well as NHL and NCAA head coaches and players daily.

The Arlington, Massachusetts, native began his writing career in hockey in 2001, when the Boston Bruins raised one of his childhood idols, Ray Bourque’s No. 77, to the rafters before their 2001–02 season opener. For 22 of his 25 years as a hockey reporter, Murphy covered the Bruins daily, including their victorious 2011 Stanley Cup run and their runs to the 2013 and 2019 Finals, multiple NHL drafts and countless Stanley Cup playoffs. He did all that for the Boston Metro, NHL.com, NESN.com and ESPN Boston.

In addition to his print work covering the Bruins, Murphy also made regular TV appearances on NESN, Fox 25 Boston, ESPN and NHL Network. From 2008 to 2012, Murphy hosted The Hockey Primetime Show on SiriusXM NHL Network Radio and made numerous appearances on national and international radio shows.

Ironically, his three years not covering the Bruins were spent covering their archrivals, the Montreal Canadiens. From 2012 to 2015, Murphy was based in Montreal and covered the Canadiens for NHL.com and TSN.ca. He also appeared regularly on TSN 690 radio and CTV.

Murphy returned to Boston in 2015 and left the media business to work in sales and marketing for LiveBarn, a Montreal-based sports streaming company, for four years. In 2019, Murphy once again became a Bruins beat reporter, this time writing for Boston Hockey Now. He spent four seasons working for BHN before arriving at RG in 2024 and also dedicated more time to The Eye Test podcast.

Meet All Our Experts
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Read our
Privacy Policy
.