"Give Them a Three-year Runway" - Justin Pugh on New York Giants' Future Plans At Quarterback

6 min read
Dec 12, 2024, 12:46 PM
The Giants are 2-11 and in clear need of a new franchise quarterback after parting ways with Daniel Jones

The Giants are in clear need of a new franchise quarterback after parting ways with Daniel Jones (Photo by Luke Hales/Getty Images)

Former longtime New York Giants offensive lineman Justin Pugh believes there's no doubt that his former team is selecting a quarterback with one of the top picks in next year's draft.

The Giants are 2-11 and in clear need of a new franchise quarterback after parting ways with Daniel Jones. After signing Jones to a four-year, $160 million contract, the 27-year-old had fizzled as the franchise quarterback, going 3-13 over the past two seasons prior to being released at the end of November.

With New York on track to gain one of the top two selections in the 2025 NFL Draft, Pugh makes a prediction that they'll select either Colorado's Shedeur Sanders or Miami's Cam Ward with one of those picks.

"They're going to do it," said Pugh to RG when asked if the Giants are picking a quarterback next season. "There's too much pressure not to do it. If you take Travis Hunter instead of Shedeur or Cam Ward, there's going to be riots in the streets. Everybody lives and breathes by the quarterback. I'm much firmer of a believer that you pay your QB a certain percentage of salary cap and young QB's fit that bill."

A Quick Re-Tool

Pugh – who played with the Giants between 2013 and 2017 and was also teammates with Jones during the 2023 season in New York – says the team will likely "mortgage" the future in an effort to win immediately in the post-Jones era.  

That means the Giants will be looking for their franchise quarterback as soon as this offseason; a "Jayden Daniels" type of passer.  

"They have more money to spend in free agency," said Pugh. "That's what the Giants are going to do because they're not going to give GM Joe Schoen a three-year extension. If Joe Schoen's back, you better go win next year. I better see a Jayden Daniels next season. They're going to mortgage the future to win next year and try to save their jobs. I don't know if that's the best way to build a football team."

Pugh believes the key turning point in the franchise's trajectory is when the Giants prioritized re-signing Jones rather than franchise RB Saquon Barkley during the 2023 offseason. New York signed Jones to a monster contract in the offseason while placing the non-exclusive franchise tag on Barkley.

The two-time Pro Bowl running back would eventually sign with the team's divisional rivals, the Philadelphia Eagles, this year. Barkley has since emerged as the NFL's top running back, leading the league in rushing yards (1,623) and yards per attempt (6.1). He's also helped lead Philadelphia to a resurgent season after a disappointing finish last year, with an 11-2 mark through 13 games.

"I think the Giants and Joe Schoen messed up with Saquon Barkley," said Pugh.

"He was more than just a running back. If you're paying receivers $35 million a year, you're telling me you can't pay Barkley $500K more per year to get into the $13 million mark? If the top receivers are worth $30 million, Saquon has to be in the $15 million range.  

"When you have that drama for two years drag on and you draft guys early in the draft that aren't All-Pro's and you have to bench Evan Neal – and he's probably not going to be with the Giants moving forward either – it starts to develop this track record where people are coming after Joe Schoen," Pugh continues to say.

The Big Apple Pressure

The Giants haven't won a playoff game since winning the Super Bowl in 2011 and have just two playoff appearances during that time frame. They've also had five different full-time head coaches, indicating that the franchise has been rather unstable.

"When you are constantly trying to overturn a team in one or two years and there's pressure, if you don't make this team into the Detroit Lions in two years, you're a failure," says Pugh. "It impacts decision-making and it forces you to do things to win now and not to win into the future."

Despite Schoen's recent shaky track record as general manager, Pugh argues in favor of giving the 45-year-old a three-year runway to rebuild for the future.

"Give them a three-year runway," says Pugh of Schoen's future with the Giants.

"I know people are going to freak out, people came for my head. They're like, 'Off with his head for saying he should be given three more years.' Let them build for the future – Joe Schoen's got to hit in the draft. You can't draft any more guys and not have them hit, that's going to hurt your track record. It starts with allowing those guys to have some structure, have some confidence they're going to be there for a little awhile and allow them to truly carry out their vision."

DJ Siddiqi
DJ Siddiqi
Sports Reporter

DJ Siddiqi is a sports reporter who focuses on football, basketball and pro wrestling. He has covered some of the biggest sporting events, including the NBA Finals and Wrestlemania and often interviews high-profile athletes on a weekly basis. Siddiqi has interviewed the likes of Dan Marino, Emmitt Smith, Shaquille O'Neal, Tony Hawk and Giannis Antetokounmpo. His previous experience includes working as a lead NBA writer at CBS Sports and 247 Sports in addition to working as a beat reporter covering the NFL and the Denver Broncos at Bleacher Report. Follow Siddiqi for exclusive one-on-one interviews and analysis on key topics in sports

Interests:
NFL
NBA
NCAAF
NCAAB
NHL
Travel
Interviews

More RG Exclusive Interviews

04/01/2025
"It Was Really Exciting": Danny Stutsman on Meeting With Dallas Cowboys at NFL Combine
NFL Draft prospect and former Oklahoma Sooners linebacker Danny Stutsman names the teams he met with at the NFL Combine and how the Dallas Cowboys meeting stood out to him
"It Was Really Exciting": Danny Stutsman on Meeting With Dallas Cowboys at NFL Combine
03/27/2025
“Saquon Changed the Conversation About Running Backs” – Barry Sanders on Barkley’s Impact, Mount Rushmore of RBs
Detroit Lions great Barry Sanders details how the Philadelphia Eagles’ Saquon Barkley has brought value back to running backs and names his Mount Rushmore for the position
“Saquon Changed the Conversation About Running Backs” – Barry Sanders on Barkley’s Impact, Mount Rushmore of RBs
03/26/2025
“They Both Want to Win”: Patrick Surtain II Praises Bo Nix-Sean Payton Duo Driving Broncos’ Resurgence
Patrick Surtain II highlights how Bo Nix and Sean Payton’s shared mindset sparked a playoff return for the Broncos
“They Both Want to Win”: Patrick Surtain II Praises Bo Nix-Sean Payton Duo Driving Broncos’ Resurgence
03/19/2025
Braden Fiske on Los Angeles Rams' Decision to Move On From Cooper Kupp: "Obviously, It Was Tough”
Braden Fiske opens up on the Los Angeles Rams' decision to move on from Cooper Kupp and his thoughts on the addition of Davante Adams
Braden Fiske on Los Angeles Rams' Decision to Move On From Cooper Kupp:  "Obviously, It Was Tough”
03/17/2025
“We’re Heading in the Right Direction”: Patrick Surtain II Believes the Broncos Are Super Bowl Contenders in 2025
Patrick Surtain II details why the Denver Broncos can develop into a Super Bowl contender and the biggest thing he's learned from head coach Sean Payton
“We’re Heading in the Right Direction”: Patrick Surtain II Believes the Broncos Are Super Bowl Contenders in 2025
03/04/2025
CeeDee Lamb on Cowboys Potentially Adding Receiver Through NFL Draft: “Just Looking For a Great Compliment”
Dallas Cowboys' CeeDee Lamb gives his thoughts on the 2025 NFL Draft and the wide receiver prospects who stand out most to him
CeeDee Lamb on Cowboys Potentially Adding Receiver Through NFL Draft: “Just Looking For a Great Compliment”
03/02/2025
“I Knew I Wanted to Be a Quarterback”: Justin Arth’s Unconventional Path
Justin Arth's journey from YouTube-trained QB to pro football is a testament to perseverance in a game where nothing is guaranteed
“I Knew I Wanted to Be a Quarterback”: Justin Arth’s Unconventional Path
02/27/2025
“Go About It and Attack It”: Jim Harbaugh on Chargers' Approach to 2025 NFL Draft, Connections to Michigan
Los Angeles Chargers head coach Jim Harbaugh on his approach to the NFL Combine and NFL Draft, whether or not he leans towards Michigan Wolverines alumni and his thoughts on the College Football Playoff system
“Go About It and Attack It”: Jim Harbaugh on Chargers' Approach to 2025 NFL Draft, Connections to Michigan
02/24/2025
Peyton Manning Says Denver Broncos Will be 'Even Better' Next Year
Peyton Manning makes a bold prediction about the Denver Broncos and gives his thoughts on what they need to get to the next level
Peyton Manning Says Denver Broncos Will be 'Even Better' Next Year
02/18/2025
“We Left That Place Better Than We Found It”: RJ Oben on Notre Dame’s Legacy
RJ Oben’s versatility and relentless work ethic make him a top NFL Draft prospect. Will he be Notre Dame’s next big defensive star in the NFL?
“We Left That Place Better Than We Found It”: RJ Oben on Notre Dame’s Legacy

NFL Writers

Crissy Froyd
Crissy Froyd
Football Reporter

Crissy Froyd is a sports reporter of over 10 years who specializes in quarterback analysis at the high school, college and NFL level. She was mentored by Mike Leach and learned the Air Raid offense and quarterback evaluation largely under the legendary head coach. Froyd has appeared in and worked with multiple publications, including USA TODAY SMG, Sports Illustrated, NBC Sports and Saturday Down South. She also covers canine journalism for Showsight Magazine and resides in Wisconsin with her three dogs -- two German Shepherds named Faxon and Bo Nix, and one Siberian Husky named Stetson "Balto" Bennett.

Meet All Our Experts