“One of the Best Players Not in the Hall of Fame” — John Madden Says Mogilny Deserves His Spot

5 min read
Nov 7, 2024, 11:52 AM

The 2024 Hockey Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony is happening on Monday, November 11th, and there is a Russian in Pavel Datsyuk heading into the hallowed halls. However, the trendsetter for many Russians coming over to play in the NHL during the decline of the USSR, Alexander Mogilny, has yet to receive his call to the hall.  

As one of his former teammates with the New Jersey Devils, John Madden, told RG, no one was better at scoring goals.  

"As far as Mogilny, I mean, you couldn't really ask for a more prolific goal scorer," Madden said.

Mogilny has been eligible for the Hockey Hall of Fame since 2009. If you don't know his story, it is truly remarkable. Mogilny was the first Soviet player drafted to defect, joining the Buffalo Sabres in 1989.

He hit the 30-goal plateau four times with the Sabres, scoring 76 goals during the 1992-93 season. He is one of six players in NHL history to score 75 or more goals in a season. Every other member of that club is in the Hockey Hall of Fame except Mogilny.

Alexander Mogilny found success with the Buffalo Sabres, despite not being able to help them win a Stanley Cup, but would struggle during his time with the Vancouver Canucks. Mogilny found new life when the New Jersey Devils acquired him during the 1999-2000 season. He was crucial to a Stanley Cup-winning team that needed a sniper.  

While Madden and Mogilny only spent a few seasons together from 1999-2001, he saw how big of a goal scorer he was for the Devils. Mogilny always knew when to spark his team and get the big, series-changing goals.  

"It was crazy how many key goals he scored for us at the right moments, at the right times, whether it was regular season or playoffs; he just had that knack for burying goals that mattered," Madden continued.

If you look at his resume, Mogilny's is as good, if not better, than many who have been called to the HHOF in the past.

Mogilny is one of the best offensive forwards and goal-scorers in NHL history. In 990 games, he recorded 1,032 points (473 goals and 559 assists), a 1.04-point-per-game pace. For comparison’s sake, Pierre Turgeon got in with a 1.02-point-per-game pace.

Mogilny is a member of the Triple Gold Club, having won an Olympic Gold Medal, a World Championship Gold Medal, and a Stanley Cup. He got that Stanley Cup in New Jersey in 2000. He also has a World Junior Championship Gold Medal to his name. If you look at those in the Hockey Hall of Fame, there are 30 members in the Hall of Fame from that exclusive club.  

"To me, Alexander Mogilny is one of the best players not to be in the Hockey Hall of Fame," Madden said.  

Having 10 years of experience (SiriusXM NHL Network Radio, Rod Pedersen Show, Raw Mike Richards Show, and more) covering the Devils, the NHL along with College Football, the NFL, and the tennis circuit Jim Biringer has wealth of sports knowledge. As one of Jim's hockey coaches put it he is a "student of the game." During his time as a sports reporter, Biringer has covered some of the biggest events including most recently the 2024 Stanley Cup Final along with several NHL Drafts. He is also the host of the Full Press Hockey Podcast and Final Word on Hockey plus Around Campus - The College Football Podcast.

Interests:
NFL
tennis
NHL
College Football

More RG Exclusive Interviews

NHL Writers

Daria Tuboltseva
Daria Tuboltseva
Hockey Reporter

Daria went to St. Petersburg State University and earned a bachelor of international journalism. Working as a sports journalist from 2014, from 2016 as a hockey journalist. Covered 5 World Championships, 2022 Winter Olympics, 2020 World Juniors, 6 Gagarin Cup Finals. 

Owner of a telegram channel Coolest Game on Earth.

Integrative nutritionist specializing on sports nutritionology.

Marco D'Amico
Marco D'Amico
Hockey Reporter

Marco D'Amico is a beat reporter covering the Montreal Canadiens and the NHL Draft, while also being a recurring guest on TSN690 and BPM Sports. His work primarily on NHL CBA breakdowns and prospect analysis, all while covering the Montreal Canadiens on a day-to-day basis.

Sergey Demidov
Sergey Demidov
Head of News Department

Sergey has been in sports journalism since 2007 as a reporter, editor, and manager. He has covered the Olympic Games, soccer World Cups, the World Cup of Hockey in 2016, the European championships, the Stanley Cup Finals, IOC events, and many others. Sergey interviewed the sport's greatest athletes, coaches, and executives. Since 2016, he has been an Independent Senior Editor of NHL.com/ru.

James Murphy
James Murphy
NHL Reporter

With 24 years of experience (SiriusXM NHL Network Radio, ESPN Boston, NESN, NHL.com, etc.) covering the Bruins, the NHL, NCAA and junior hockey, and more, Jimmy Murphy’s hockey black book is filled with Hall of Famers, current players, coaches, management, scouts and a wide array of hockey media personalities that have lived in and around this great game. For 22 of his 24 years as a hockey and sports reporter, Murphy covered the Bruins on a daily basis, including their victorious 2011 Stanley Cup run and their runs to the 2013 and 2019 Finals. Murphy is currently a co-host, along with Pierre McGuire, on The Eye Test Podcast.

Show More